Alexander hamilton document 1 and thomas jefferson document 2 had very different visions of what the united states should look like. Included in the zip file are pdf and editable ppt version of. History alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson quizlet. Comparing the ideals of hamilton and jefferson read the following idealscharacteristics and decide whether they are federalist or democraticrepublican. Alexander hamilton was a founding father, a constitutional convention delegate. Chapter 5 continues with the theme begun at the end of chapter 4 by providing an empirical test of what affect abandoning the common law has on political actors. Federalist ideal democraticrepublican alexander hamilton and john adams were party leaders thomas jefferson and james madison were party leaders. Washington concerned about the constitutionality of the united states bank, asked jefferson and hamilton each to give their opinions on the. Using the information in the documents and your general knowledge of th.
Unfortunately, george washington thought theyd be great together and put hamilton as his secretary of the treasury and jefferson as secretary of state. In chapter 6 of the private life of thomas jefferson by hamilton w. Thomas jefferson seemed to disagree on everything from the economy, the national debt, states rights, trade, how to interpret the constitution, and whether to support britain or france. Alexander hamilton was born into obscurity in the british west indies, but. Read the information about jefferson and hamiltons differing views about government. The papers of alexander hamilton 17571804 cover the years 1708 to 1917, with the bulk of material dating from 1777 to 1804. His proslavery views were shaped not only by money and status but also by. Opponents asserted, for example, that a central government could not be sustained and also pressed the significance of. Thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton had to different views on how america should function. Whose vision of america won outhamiltons or jeffersons. Thomas jefferson papers, 1606 to 1827 manuscript division 7 american memory 6 the thomas jefferson papers at the library of congress. Hamilton, a staunch federalist, and jefferson with his agrarian democracy, could not agree on much in regards to the structure and role of government. Hisfather,peterjefferson,was of welsh descent, not of aristocratic birth, but of that yeoman class which constitutes the backbone of all societies.
Thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton debate at the. In a second cabinet meeting, jefferson and hamilton debate on whether the united states should assist the french in. Thomas jefferson, benjamin franklin, john adams, james madison, alexander hamilton, and john marshall, whose names pull up sites in the thousands. Online bookstores follow suit with hundreds of titles. The elder jefferson had uncommon powers both of mind and body. How does the human element affect political developments. Alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson yahoo answers. Hamilton accepted when burr challenged him to a duel. The impact on america of alexander hamilton and thomas.
Discuss each mans vision and the pros and cons of each vision and assess. You can edit this venn diagram using creately diagramming tool and include in your reportpresentationwebsite. Alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson were both appointed to george washingtons cabinet, despite differing opinions on the role of the government. Alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson a more perfect union. Their relationship and differences are topics covered on the. Comme thomas jefferson, hamilton est elitiste et individualiste, ce qui. Alexander hamilton to thomas jefferson, april 12, 1791. Jefferson dbq in the history of america, thomas jefferson, the secretary of state, and hamilton, the secretary of the treasury, were two of the greatest leaders of our country. Do we have a hamiltonian balance of power or jeffersonian one. John adams noted that hamilton and jefferson agree about nothing, and that they argued whenever they were together. Jefferson and aaron burr tied for the presidency in the electoral college, and. Perhaps the only things they agreed about were 1 a war of independence from england was necessary, and 2 aaron burr w. Paul finkelman recently wrote a fascinating piece in the new york times focusing on thomas jeffersons views on race. Thomas jefferson there was a time when i should have ballanced between mr.
Since alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson had such an influence in the development of our country, it is fitting that we study their lives and philosophies. Few people knew that jefferson had authored the declaration of independence, which had yet to become holy writ for americans. Thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton flashcards quizlet. Province united christ church ministry 23 now the same john had his raiment of camels hair, and a leathern girdle about his loins. They both showed difference between them, when it comes to their thoughts and ideas. Cut each quote and make enough quotes for every group. Alexander hamilton and thomas jeffersons different visions for america amanda guay essay history america publish your bachelors or masters thesis, dissertation, term paper or essay. Letter to elbridge gerry may 1797 it was by the sober sense of our citizens that we were safely and steadily conducted from monarchy to. Thomas jefferson i youth and training thomas jefferson was born upon a frontier estate in albemarle county,virginia,april,1743. Hamilton vs jefferson thomas jefferson vs alexander hamilton. Hamilton wanted to concentrate power in a centralized federal government with limited access and jefferson wished to diffuse it among all the eligible freemen of the time. Making the right choice when leaders face a dilemma can have historic consequences.
Free essays on alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson dbq. Jefferson grew up in virginia to a well respected family, while hamilton was born in the caribbean island of st. Other men, most notably james madison and john adams, also contributed to the formation of political parties, but hamilton and jefferson. It is a clever, rap music account of alexander hamilton, the nations first secretary of the treasury and jeffersons arch political foe. Ron chernow has given us valuable portraits as well of hamiltons major contemporaries, including not just washington, thomas jefferson, james madison, john adams, and aaron burr, but also abigail adams, hamiltons wellborn wife elizabeth schuyler, her father philip schuyler a titan in new york politics, and a bevy of secondary players. The policies of alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson department of state, department of treasury, department of war, attorney general, postmaster general. Jefferson was always deeply committed to slavery, and even more deeply hostile to the welfare of blacks, slave or free. However, they both believed the future of the american. Philosophically speaking, thomas jefferson based his political ideals from the writings of john locke who assumed that the function of the government as a trustee of the people is to protect the rights, property, and liberty of the individual, in the pursuit of happiness. From left to right, john adams, robert morris, alexander hamilton, and thomas jefferson. This homework is designed to allow students to illustrate the differences between the policies and ideas of alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson. Discuss each mans vision and the pros and cons of each vision and assess, historically, which one you think would have been more attractive to americans at the time, being sure to use specific examples and.
Read the information about jefferson and hamilton s differing views about government. Chapter 2 hamilton and jefferson the men and their. Thomas jefferson put this primary axiom when he wrote the declaration of independence, stating that governments created by. The impact on america of alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton were completely at odds in their vision on how america was to develop. He is portrayed by daveed diggs in the original cast. Pierson 1862, edmund bacon, an overseer on thomas jefferson s plantation monticello from 1806 until 1822, tells about jefferson s dress and hygiene. What thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton teach us about donald trump. It ended only with the death of hamilton in a pistol duel, felled by aaron burr, jeffersons vice president. Alexander hamilton vs thomas jefferson chart thomas. Search results for thomas jefferson papers, 1606 to 1827. The jefferson bible the life and morals of jesus of nazareth extracted from the four gospels originally compiled by thomas jefferson edited by charles m. At age 14, the young jefferson inherited his fathers plantation and slaves. To thomas jefferson from alexander hamilton, 10 june 1793. Jefferson also believed that the constitution did not give.
Anger and frustration take the reins whenever they are in a room together, but after an intense late night encounter in the treasury department, they realize that the line between. Jefferson and hamilton quotes cut each quote and make enough. What thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton teach us about. Thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton were lifelong rivals and political enemies. Page 6 the second office of the government is honorable and easy, the first is but a splendid misery. Hamilton believed that the common people of america often acted foolishly, while jefferson had a lot of faith in common people such as farmers. Jefferson, who was american ambassador in france from 1785 to 1789, never spoke french well, whereas hamilton, who never set foot in europe, spoke french fluently and. The less government interferes with the economy, the better. Jeffersons objections to the bank thomas jefferson objected strongly to hamiltons proposal for a national bank. These disagreements quickly split american political leaders into two groups. Among the reasons he and his followers gave for their opposition, the following were the most important. Alexander hamilton alexander hamiltons support of thomas jefferson over aaron burr in the 1800 u. Hamilton vs jefferson essay example research papers.
How did hamilton and jefferson s differ in their views of the constitution. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The project gutenberg ebook of thomas jefferson by henry. Alexander hamilton, one of the most important people of the time, was the first secretary of the treasury. Thomas jefferson vs alexander hamilton, one of the chief rivalries at the center of american politics through the first two decades, split the nation by ideology and purpose. What are the differences between alexander hamilton and. Federalist era dbq question although alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson were two great leaders in united states history, they both had very different views of government and of the economy. Utilizing federal power to modernize the nation, he convinced congress to use an elastic interpretation of the constitution to pass laws that jefferson deemed unconstitutional. Then fill out the venn diagram summarizing their likes and differences. Both were important figures in the american revolution and the constitutional debate that followed. How did the beliefs of hamilton and jefferson translate into policies during the early republic.
The comptroller of the treasury has reported to me that on examining the subsisting contracts between the united states and the government of france and the farmers general and a comparison thereof with the foreign. Letter from thomas jefferson blasts alexander hamiltons. Thomas jefferson is the 3rd president and 2nd vice president of the u. Among americas founding fathers, no one has seen his fortune rise dramatically over the.
Chapter 4 hamilton, jefferson, and the first national. Roosevelt more hamiltonian or jeffersonian in his approach toward trusts. During the 1800 presidential elections, thomas jefferson. From index to the thomas jefferson papers washington, d. To alexander hamilton from thomas jefferson, 4 february 1793. Alexander hamiltonthomas jefferson works archive of our own. Quotations by alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson. The thing about alexander hamilton is that people saw his plans for public credit, banks, and federal assumption of state debt and got very frightened madison and jefferson especially. In this lesson, youll learn about the relationship between thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton. In terms of political philosophies, alexander hamilton had a completely different view form thomas jefferson. Alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson worksheets.
Alexander hamilton, philadelphia, october 15, 1792 hamilton in monticello. Jefferson alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson were both important founding fathers in the early days of the american nation, yet they despised each other. Difference between hamilton and jefferson compare the. Alexander hamiltonthomas jefferson works archive of.
It was this that kept our two secretaries, jefferson and hamilton, on friendly. Of these men were thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton, and both played major roles on impacting the new nation. Alexander hamilton vs thomas jefferson thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton are two very different, yet similar, people. What was the relationship between alexander hamilton and. In a shameless, but not plotless, bdsm smut, thomas jefferson 20 and alexander hamilton 21 have been enemies in the cabinet for a year now since it was assembled. The case for alexander hamiltons vision we live, without question, in hamiltons america, says stephen f. Give an example in the news or in your experience that supports your answer in question number.
Illustration of four delegates to the continental congress that began in colonial america, 1774. This chapter seeks to describe the relation between alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson from hamiltons point of view. He thought states should charter banks that could issue money. Of all the piling on thomas jefferson has endured the last 20 years, most of it unfounded and undeserved, much credit can be given to the incredible popularity of the play, hamilton. There was a fascinating debate on the radio this evening comparing the political philosophies of alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson. I consider the foundation of the constitution as laid on this ground. How could you compare and contrast thomas jefferson and.
Weiss there can be no time, no state of things, in which credit is not essential to the nation, especially as long as nations in general continue to use it as a resource in war. Questions for discussion could be posed throughout the year, such as. He died with burrs bullet in his chest in weehawken, new jersey, on july 12, 1804. Alexander hamilton document 1 and thomas jefferson. Jan 28, 2011 alexander hamilton led the federalists and focused mainly on the city businesses as well as manufacturing interests of the seaports. Thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton disagreed on many things.
What were the key life experiences of hamilton and jefferson that help us understand their divergent views. My team is on hamilton s side, so id be very much obliged for any pros for hamilton and cons for jefferson. Alexander hamilton to thomas jefferson, 15 april 1791. Nov 19, 2008 my us history class is having a debate between hamilton s views ie. Lets dig deeper and learn about their bitter relationship. Tall and lanky, with a freckled complexion and auburn hair, jefferson, 46, was taken aback by the adulation being heaped upon the new treasury secretary, alexander hamilton, who had streaked to prominence in his absence.
What did thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton agree on. On the other side, the antifederalists whom were led by thomas jefferson represented the rural farmers and southern interests. Two of americas founding fathers went headtohead in an ageold clash at the nixon presidential library. Their competing legacies, like the twin strands of dna, continue to shape our country to this day.
With the federalists favoring more federal involvement and the antifederalists. The revolutionary writings of alexander hamilton edited and with an. This guide directs to information on thomas jefferson and his relationship with alexander hamilton, including personal rivalries as well as conflicts taking place. Title alexander hamilton to thomas jefferson, april 12, 1791. Hamilton and jefferson were popular members of the society in the period after the revolution. Chapter 4 hamilton, jefferson, and the first national bank.
He serves as an antagonist for the majority of act 2. Alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson 821 words cram. How could you compare and contrast thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton. Hamilton believed that there should be a strong federal government, jefferson believed that the states should be stronger. Two of their disagreements that are still pretty relevant. Thomas jefferson unlike hamilton, thomas jefferson was an aristocrat by birth and a democrat by conviction. Whose vision do you think has survived to the present day. That all powers not delegated to the united states, by the constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states or to the people. Despite washingtons cautionary words, two of his closest advisors, thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton, helped to form the factions that led to the dual party system under which the u. Chapter 2 hamilton and jefferson the men and their philosophies. Quotations by alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson on the subject of public credit compiled by phillip w.
Alexander hamilton and thomas jeffersons different. In fact jefferson never planned to work with hamilton until washington appointed jefferson his first secretary of the. Using the worksheet and quiz, you can see how much you know about thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton. The quarrel of jefferson and hamilton the atlantic. The policies of alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson. General correspondence, speeches and writings, legal papers, financial papers, family papers, miscellany, 1998 addition, 2017 addition, and oversize. A brief comparison of the pointsofview of alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson on various political topics of the time period. Find an answer to your question alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson often took the same side on issues. Thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton differed in that hamilton believed in the idea of a strong government with huge oversight with voters limited to those of appropriate educational backgrounds, while jefferson believed in the idea of a small government with minimal. Jefferson and hamilton is the story of the fierce struggleboth public and, ultimately, bitterly personalbetween these two titans. Alexander hamilton to thomas jefferson, 15 april 1791 author hamilton, alexander recipient jefferson, thomas date 15 april 1791 ancestor groups the debt to france. Although they both lead the country, thats where the similarities end as they had opposing views on everything. Apr 03, 2009 alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson thomas jefferson v alexander hamilton. Alexander hamilton journal of american history oxford.
1182 1516 788 320 737 895 415 463 1450 1048 1455 58 398 568 214 51 873 1302 1149 904 314 1456 828 639 806 152 1538 52 188 263 666 1575 79 392 1112 1024 758 778 435 872 1185 475 714 1039 515 810 1070 1223